Chapter 2 - The Threshold of Secrets
“Furious doesn't even begin to cover it, Julian,” I snapped, my fingers digging so hard into my steering wheel that my knuckles turned bone-white.
Julian grabbed my arm, his face pale and slick with sudden sweat. His voice was frantic, pitched high in a way I had never heard in the eight years we had been married. “Chloe, wait. Think about what you’re doing. My mother... she’s old-school. She has her ways, her harsh methods of discipline from the old country, but if you go over there guns blazing, you’ll tear this family apart. Let me handle her. Let me talk to her first.”
“She put a trash bag on our six-year-old child to suffocate the weight off her and beat her with a belt because she ate a Christmas cookie,” I hissed, shaking his hand off my arm with a violent jerk. “There is nothing to talk about, Julian. There is only a police report and a prison cell.”
Before he could block the door, I bolted out to my car, slamming the driver’s side door shut. I checked the inside pocket of my coat. My phone was still there, tucked securely in the lining, its voice recorder active and flashing a tiny, steady red dot in the hidden app interface.
The drive to Victoria Moretti’s affluent Saddle River estate took twenty agonizing minutes. Every stoplight felt like a personal insult; every red glare mocked the furious pounding of my blood. Victoria lived in a sprawling, manicured manor where the lawns were always pristine and the secrets kept inside were always pitch-black.
When I pulled up her long, winding driveway, her dark green Mercedes was parked in the open bay.
I didn't knock. I bypassed the front entrance entirely, walked straight to the side kitchen door, and twisted the handle. It was unlocked—just like it always was for family.
Victoria was standing by her marble kitchen island, pouring herself a cup of black coffee from a silver pot. She wore a tailored beige knit sweater and designer slacks, her silver hair styled into an immaculate blowout. She looked like a wealthy suburban grandmother hosting a book club, not a woman who had tortured a child a few hours prior.
When she saw me burst through the door, she didn't flinch. She didn't look surprised. She merely set down her coffee cup with a measured, deliberate click.
“Chloe,” Victoria sighed, rolling her eyes as if I were an annoying salesperson tracking mud onto her imported tiles. “You look hysterical. Honestly, it’s unbecoming.”
I reached into my coat, pulled out my phone, and tapped the screen to play the audio back on speakerphone.
“Grandma,” Elena’s timid voice filled the quiet kitchen. “Why?” “Because I ate cookies. She said I had to sweat them out so I wouldn't get fat... And she pulled out her belt.”
The audio looped into silence. Victoria stared at the phone. For a fraction of a second, her composure wavered. A tiny twitch betrayed the corner of her left eye. But then, like a practiced actress slipping back into a familiar role, her face hardened into absolute, unyielding coldness.
“Your daughter needs to learn how to control her body before it’s too late!” my mother-in-law snapped at me, crossing her arms over her chest, her voice dripping with venom. “You feed her garbage, you coddle her, and you let her turn into a soft, undisciplined creature. I was doing you a favor. My husband taught me discipline with a belt, and look at me—I built this family's empire. A little tough love never killed anyone.”
I stood frozen for a second, my phone recording every single damning, psychotic word.
“You beat a child,” I whispered, my voice shaking with rage. “You wrapped her in plastic like garbage. I am calling the police, Victoria. And then I am going to make sure you never, ever see your granddaughter again.”
Victoria didn't scream. She didn't beg. Instead, a slow, ugly, knowing smile spread across her face. She walked closer to the marble island, leaning her weight forward on her palms.
“Go ahead, Chloe. Call them,” Victoria whispered, her voice laced with a terrifying confidence. “Tell the police. Tell the world. But before you do... ask your precious husband Julian why he didn't call the police the last time it happened.”
May you like
My breath caught in my throat. “What are you talking about?”
“Ask Julian,” Victoria laughed softly, a harsh, grating sound. “Ask him whose idea it really was to teach Elena how a Moretti woman stays slim. Ask him why he didn't look surprised when he saw those marks on her back.”
