Chapter 3 - The Descent
The commotion in the backyard had mercifully gone unnoticed by most of the guests, who were still distracted by the blaring music and the children splashing in the pool. But my husband, Glen, was too observant to miss the rising tide of hostility. He reached us just as Clara tried to wrench her wrist from my grip.
“Hey, hey! What is going on here?” Glen stepped between us, placing a firm, grounding hand on my shoulder. His eyes darted between my rigid posture and Clara’s panicked expression. “Clara, are you okay? Sarah, why are you holding her arm like that?”
“Ask her,” I choked out, my voice shaking as I pointed a trembling finger at the vintage gold locket resting against her chest. “Ask her why our daughter recognized my father’s face trapped behind that glass.”
Glen frowned, looking down at the necklace. “Sarah, that’s just a piece of old family jewelry. You said yourself it belonged to your grandmother—”
“It’s not just jewelry, Glen!” I cut him off, my voice rising. I turned back to Clara, who was now backing away toward the sliding glass door that led into the house, her breath coming in shallow, ragged gasps. “My father didn’t disappear at sea three years ago, did he, Clara? His yacht didn't just drift away. You staged it.”
Clara let out a harsh, defensive laugh, though her eyes were wild. “You are out of your absolute mind! The police investigated for months! The Coast Guard spent a fortune looking for Arthur! Are you seriously accusing me of—of murder based on what a three-year-old babied about a picture?”
“She didn't say murder, Clara,” I whispered, stepping forward until I was right in her face. “She said he’s in there. And looking at how terrified you look right now, I think he’s alive. Somewhere very close.”
Before Clara could dart past us into the house, Glen stepped sideways, blocking the doorway with his broad frame. He might have been skeptical a moment ago, but the sheer terror radiating from Clara’s face had convinced him something was deeply, horribly wrong.
“We’re going inside,” Glen said quietly, his voice dropping into a tone that brooked no argument. “All of us. Now.”
We moved through the sliding glass door in a tense, silent procession. I scooped Ariel up into my arms, burying my face in her curls as she whimpered softly against my neck. Clara walked ahead of us, her heels clicking sharply against the hardwood floor of the kitchen, her hands tightly clenched into fists at her sides.
“Where are your keys, Clara?” I demanded as she headed toward the hallway instead of the basement door.
“I don't know what you're talking about—”
“Don't lie to me!” I snapped, slamming my hand against the kitchen counter. “Where is the key to the root cellar beneath the old tool shed? Or did you convert the storm shelter under your suburban garage into something a bit more permanent?”
Clara froze. The color drained completely from her face, leaving her looking like a ghost in the bright afternoon kitchen light.
Glen’s eyes widened in horror as the pieces clicked together. “Clara... tell me she’s wrong. Tell me you didn't.”
Clara didn't answer. Instead, she spun around, her eyes darting toward the front door like a trapped animal. But Glen was faster. He lunged forward, blocking the exit and grabbing a heavy brass key ring hanging from the key hook by the pantry.
“You never liked him, did you?” I said, my voice trembling with a cold, terrifying clarity as I set Ariel down gently on the kitchen island, telling her to stay with a reassuring stroke of her hair. “You married my father for his estate, his money, his comfortable life. But when he finally caught wind of what you were doing—when he threatened to cut you out of his will—you didn't divorce him. You buried him alive.”
“I didn't bury him!” Clara shrieked, finally breaking, her composure shattering into a jagged mess of hysteria and fury. Tears sprang to her eyes, but they weren't tears of remorse; they were tears of pure rage. “Do you have any idea what it was like living with him? The constant control? The gaslighting? He deserved to rot! He thought he was so smart, always watching everyone, always keeping receipts!”
“So you drugged him,” I said, feeling my stomach turn inside out. “You staged his disappearance on his boat, left his yacht drifting, and locked him away in the heavily reinforced storm shelter beneath your property.”
May you like
“He has food! He has water! He has electricity!” Clara screamed, lunging at us before Glen caught her by the shoulders and shoved her back against the wall. “He’s alive! He’s right down there! If you let him out, he’ll destroy all of us!”
I didn't wait to hear another word. I snatched the heavy brass keys from Glen’s hand, turned toward the basement stairs hidden behind the pantry door, and pulled the latch.
